
Buyer Side vs Seller Side Quality of Earnings
A seller’s quality of earnings report can make an acquisition process easier to navigate. It does not answer every question a particular buyer needs to resolve. The practical issue is how to use the seller’s work while preserving a financial review that fits the buyer’s valuation, financing, and operating plan.
Buyer-side and seller-side QoE examine many of the same records. Their differences lie in the client, timing, priorities, access, and permitted use of the report. Understanding those differences helps both sides avoid duplicated work and misplaced expectations.
The differences that matter in a transaction
| Issue | Seller-side QoE | Buyer-side QoE |
|---|---|---|
| Commissioning party | Seller or selling shareholders | Prospective buyer or investor |
| Main decision | How to prepare and support the financial presentation | Whether the target supports the buyer’s acquisition case |
| Typical timing | Before or during a sale process | During acquisition diligence, often after initial terms |
| Priority questions | Earnings presentation, readiness, likely buyer challenges | Buyer-specific risks, assumptions, financing and deal terms |
| Access | Often benefits from early management access | Depends on the sale process and data-room permissions |
| Report use | Distribution and reliance depend on the engagement | Use and reliance also depend on engagement terms |
| Follow-up | May need updates as trading changes | May need targeted procedures and a closing update |
These are general engagement patterns, not mandatory rules. The signed scope and the facts of the deal control what the advisor actually does.
What seller-side QoE can accomplish
A seller can use the review to identify accounting inconsistencies before several bidders ask about them. It can also assemble support for proposed adjustments and explain unusual results in a consistent way.
For example, a business might have changed billing systems midway through the historical period. A seller-side team can reconcile the old and new datasets and document the effect on revenue reporting. Buyers then have a clearer starting point for their own analysis.
Providers such as Withum and CLA describe seller-side diligence or QoE services. A seller should still agree which records will be reconciled, how proposed adjustments will be evaluated, and what happens if the evidence contradicts management’s original presentation.
An externally prepared seller report should not simply reproduce the seller’s preferred number. Its usefulness depends on the work performed, evidence available, and limitations disclosed. The fact that the seller pays does not, by itself, establish either bias or reliability.
What the buyer still needs to test
The acquisition operating model
The seller’s normalization may assume one replacement executive. A strategic buyer might retain the management team, while an individual buyer may take on some duties personally. Those structures have different costs.
The buyer should understand the historical business before adding its own operating assumptions. Keep supported normalization separate from speculative synergies. A cost reduction that needs integration work is not already embedded in historical earnings.
The latest trading period
A seller report can become dated during a long process. Compare the covered period with current monthly results. Ask whether customer losses, price changes, unusual collections, or margin pressure have emerged since the report’s cutoff.
A refresh should do more than append a new income statement. Decide which analyses need updating and whether the newer data changes an earlier conclusion. Unresolved issues should remain visible rather than vanish into an updated EBITDA number.
Working capital and debt-like matters
Both advisors may examine operating balances, but the transaction agreement determines the final treatment. The buyer’s financial team and counsel need consistent definitions for the working capital mechanism and any debt-like items.
Avoid assuming an accounting label settles the negotiation. An accrued expense may require careful consideration of recurrence, payment timing, the agreed price mechanism, and potential overlap with other adjustments.
Can the buyer rely on the seller’s report
Read the report’s permitted-use language and discuss it with the advisor and counsel. Receiving a copy, being allowed to discuss findings, and obtaining formal reliance rights are different arrangements. None should be assumed.
A buyer can consider a targeted review where the seller’s work is recent, well supported, and accessible. That approach still needs a written scope identifying which procedures will be repeated, challenged, or added. The buyer’s lender may have separate requirements.
OGScapital offers buyer-focused QoE. Its quality of earnings services provide a relevant route for discussing a buyer’s financial workstream alongside an existing seller report. Supply that report and its limitations at the scoping stage so the proposed work addresses the actual gaps.
A worked adjustment example
Assume a seller reports $1.5 million of EBITDA and proposes a $180,000 owner-compensation add-back. These figures are illustrative. The seller expects a replacement manager to cost $120,000, producing a net $60,000 earnings increase.
The buyer finds that the owner also handles technical sales. If replacing both functions costs $190,000, the original adjustment no longer reflects the buyer’s supported staffing assumption. That does not prove either advisor acted improperly. It shows why job responsibilities and the ownership plan must be explicit.
The same discipline applies to related-party rent, one-time professional fees, or a recently closed location. Identify the evidence, explain the economic assumption, and show the calculation.
Decide how much additional work is justified
Use the following sequence before commissioning a second full report:
1. Read the seller report’s scope, dates, limitations, and adjustment support.
2. Confirm access to underlying schedules and management explanations.
3. Identify buyer-specific questions and financing requirements.
4. Agree targeted or broader procedures with the buyer’s advisor.
5. Set an update process for material changes before closing.
Seller-side QoE can improve preparation. Buyer-side QoE should test the buyer’s decision. Used together with clear scopes, they can create a more efficient process without treating one party’s report as a universal answer.



